Newsletter > October 2003
Court of Appeal Declines to Determine Whether Trial Judge Wrong in Ruling Fedex Terms Offended S. 23 of the Warsaw Convention
In MDSI Mobile Data Solutions Inv. v. Federal Express Corp.,  B.C.C.A. 9 (B.C.C.A.) a shipper declared the value for carriage on a FedEx airwaybill which referred to the Warsaw Convention but as well incorporated contractual terms (including its Service Guide) which included a maximum limitation amount of $50,000. The shipment travelled from Vancouver to Memphis in the U.S.A. FedEx argued that the limitation under the Warsaw Convention of $11,427 applies. The shipper claimed for the declared value of $214, 857.41. The trial judge ruled that the contractual terms in the Guide offended the Warsaw Convention and was void. The Court of Appeal held that on a reading of the Service Guide there was no maximum limitation when the Warsaw Convention applied. The Court of Appeal found it unnecessary to reach a definite conclusion as to whether the trial judge was correct in ruling that the contractual terms in the Guide offended section 23 of the Warsaw Convention rendering such terms null and void. Section 23 provides that any provision tending to relieve the air carrier of liability or fix a lower limit than that which is laid down by the Convention is null and void.
This newsletter is published to keep our clients and friends informed of new and important legal developments. It is intended for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should not act or fail to act on anything based on any of the material contained herein without first consulting with a lawyer. The reading, sending or receiving of information from or via the newsletter does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Unless otherwise noted, all content on this newsletter (the “Content”) including images, illustrations, designs, icons, photographs, and written and other materials are copyrights, trade-marks and/or other intellectual properties owned, controlled or licensed by Fernandes Hearn LLP. The Content may not be otherwise used, reproduced, broadcast, published,or retransmitted without the prior written permission of Fernandes Hearn LLP.
Subscribe to our newsletter "The Navigator"
Fernandes Hearn LLP
155 University Avenue, Suite 700, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5H 3B7
Telephone: 416-203-9500 | Fax: 416-203-9444
A proud Canadian law firm specializing in Transportation, Insurance, Trade, Technology and Commercial Law.